Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Those Who Cannot Remember the Past …

A current series of articles in the Pittsburgh “Post-Gazette” is highlighting issues around immigration to Pittsburgh in the new economy, and rightly so.  Immigration is one of this country’s seminal political issues and one that is central to the Pittsburgh region’s economic success.

But written between the lines of this and so many other pieces on Pittsburgh’s shortcomings is the subtext that, in fact, Pittsburgh’s situation is the result of some self-inflicted wounds and “the region should have known better”.  After all, look at how other regions have done it better, prima facie, their growth outstrips ours.  As usual in these pieces, there are quoted experts in the appropriate fields: everything from social sciences to economic development to corporate leadership and all of them have theories as to what Pittsburgh could have done better.

I have to question the ages and backgrounds of these people.  After reading the first two pieces in the “P-G” series I realized how old I am and how long ago was the time of Pittsburgh’s great economic upheaval – the complete death of the steel industry.  I suspect that many of the experts, especially those located in Pittsburgh, are too young to have lived through that era.  So despite the fact that I’m about to give a hint at my age, let me say I did and ….


Pittsburgh in 2014 is a modern miracle!  Detroit’s debacle in 2014 is nothing compared to the decimated economy that was Pittsburgh.  It was literally an economic collapse of “Great Depression” proportions.  I cannot exaggerate the shadow that was thrown over daily living; even the weather seemed grayer.  And yet, Pittsburgh survived.  And then it stabilized.  And now it is growing again.  The past is not prelude.  Great societies revive and renew and reinvent themselves.  Great people do as well.  As do great, truly great cities.  That’s happening in Pittsburgh now.  With acknowledgements to Santayana and exhortations from Gautama Buddha to enjoy the present moment. Peace out for now.

No comments:

Post a Comment